Thursday, March 17, 2011

Put Down The Remote, And Step Away From The Couch

First published on MediaPost, March 16, 2011

The virtual pages of the TV Board blog are used, from time to time, to define some of the phrases and terms unique or germane to the TV industry.

Rarely, however, are these brief tutorials potentially lifesaving.

Today might be different, as we discuss a phenomenon known as the "normalcy bias."

To those unfamiliar with the concept, the term "normalcy bias" might describe "the tendency of TV viewers to channel-surf among the same 10 networks on a regular basis."

This, of course, is a SYMPTOM of the normalcy bias, but not its definition.

In reality, the normalcy bias refers to "a mental state people enter when facing a disaster. It causes people to underestimate both the possibility of a disaster occurring and its possible effects."

You should look it up yourself, on sites like Wikipedia, which, as most of you know, has been endorsed by "The Office"'s Michael Scott.


The most concerning symptom of the normalcy bias is that people "...tend to interpret warnings in the most optimistic way possible, seizing on any ambiguities to infer a less serious situation."

As the unofficial canary in the TV Board coal mine, let me be brief, providing you with as much time as possible today to learn more about the normalcy bias, and its possible existence in your life.

According to graph data buried in yesterday's Mashable story about the growth of Internet news over print news, over 60% of you still get your news from TV --  roughly double the percentage of those who rely on newspapers, and 50% more than those who get their news from the Internet.

So here's a thought:

There's some really bad stuff going on outside of your windows today.  Seriously.  If you're spending time looking at your TV, especially TV "news," to get a snapshot of reality, you'll find several hundred channels of normalcy-bias-inducing content from which to choose. 

To see if YOU'RE a victim, put down the remote, and step away from the couch.

Now might be a good time for each of us to be a bit... less optimistic.  Perhaps today we should each take a few minutes to browse the news aisles of those with whom we disagree. 

Let's face it, on many matters, there are 100 million Americans (or more) that disagree with each one of us, perhaps even strongly.  The 100 million on our side of an issue might each serve as a buffer to the normalcy bias that plagues each one of us.  After all, the normalcy bias, especially mixed with catalytic ingredients such as cannabis, or worse, pride, can create a dangerous cocktail, with side effects including cranial thickening, and mid- to long-term blindness.  (Please see the ad in People magazine for full details).

How can we, as a nation of free people, be so divided, while earthquakes and tsunamis change our physical planet, nuclear radiation spews 2 hours away from one of the world's most populated modern cities, riots erupt in capitals throughout the Middle East, the U.S. dollar approaches second class currency status, and our own government decides it will no longer defend something as time-honored as the institution of marriage?

These things are happening.  Right now.  In our world.

And spare me the vitriol - if your first reaction is to hypothesize that this is all fear-mongering and over-reaction (gee, isn't that a symptom of... nah, can't be...), I sincerely ask you to step outside of the here-and-now, and take your mind back to a not-so-long-past year, like 1991. 

Would you have believed, then, that the events of today were a mere 20 years off?  In candor, would you have believed that these events could EVER have converged in ANY year of your future?

It's from the vantage point of yesterday, that we can best diagnose the symptoms of the normalcy bias, today. 

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Beck Backers Beckoned Back

First published on MediaPost, March 9, 2011

Mainstream media has been all atwitter over the recently reported ratings decline of Glenn Beck's popular TV news program.  Year on year results appear to indicate that approximately 75 Nielsen households who watched his program in January of 2010, have now either stopped watching, or are now recording his program on a DVR, outside of Nielsen's measured window. 

This mass exodus apparently places Glenn's 5 p.m. TV show in second to last place, among Fox's six weekday talk hosts.  I mean, we're talking MSNBC territory.

The diaspora leaves just under 125 recruited Nielsen/Beck households huddled around the warm glow of their Bush41-era rear-projection sets.  (This S.W.A.G. is based on estimates of a 20,000+/- Nielsen household panel, with each household representing approximately 5,800 identically cloned homes throughout America, each containing 2.54 viewers).

The loss of 75 Nielsen households is truly staggering.  By way of example, before the great Beck collapse, the Nielsen/Beck households would have had a hard time standing 3 abreast in the ammo aisle of your local Walmart.  But with the defection of 75 households, the Nielsen/Beck remnant would barely stand out in section 303 of this weekend's Monster Truck Mayhem.  (And yes, it's on SUNDAY, SUNDAY!)

Like Beck, I, too, would love to figure out how George Soros got  ahold of those 75 names.  Thanks in large part to Beck, many are keenly aware that the billionaire Quantum fund kingpin has already, nearly singlehandedly, destroyed the currencies of five nations, and now has America firmly in his sights.

But, recruiting 75 well-insulated Nielsen/Beck households, and convincing them to watch something else -- anything else -- well, that's just plain diabolical.

Unfortunately for Glenn, and unfair stereotypes aside, the news only gets worse.  Shining the light of truth on the Soros tentacles might actually stop the extradition of many within the 125 household remnant. But how do you regain viewers, in the face of the most dreaded of all truth-killers?

I'm talking, of course, about the Nielsen recruiting bias.

To clarify, I'm not talking about the bias that Beck's mentor, Bill O'Reilly, reported in 2008, when he revealed that 26 Nielsen executives, including Susan Whiting, had donated to the Democrats, while only two had donated to the Republicans.  In a blistering response memo circulated by then-Executive VP Whiting, she was quick to point out that the 92.857% Democratic coincidence is inconsequential, in light of the Nielsen overall employee base.  The memo puts it into perspective, by stating that "less than .005% of Nielsen U.S. employees, or fewer than 30 employees, made federal political contributions." 

O'Reilly missed the perfect comeback, as .005% is nearly as insignificant as .017%, the percent of households that Nielsen measures, as a percentage of all households.

No, Glenn, the recruiting bias impacts your show, probably more than any other show, because  somewhere around 60% of all households that are asked to become Nielsen households, reportedly refuse to participate.  This majority of households  --  60+ million of them -- are not even eligible to be counted by Nielsen.  (Sounds a lot like America's majority, when it comes to socialized health care, doesn't it now?)
These ostracized households would likely detest the invasive monitoring of their every view.  They would, in most instances, summarily reject the paltry sum of inflated (and now nearly worthless) Federal Reserve Notes offered up as a ransom for the liberties and privacy of every man, woman, and child in their homes.

In other words, they would be more inclined to watch the "Glenn Beck Show."

And finally, there's Glenn's recent  warnings about Google, which can't be helping to grow his TV audience, either.  Quoting Google's former CEO, Beck alerted his viewers about the search giant's prognostication prowess:  "We know roughly who you are, roughly what you care about, roughly who your friends are. Google knows to within a foot of where you are."

Gee, sound like anybody you know?

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Censure The Censors

First published on MediaPost, March 2, 2011

Last Wednesday's intentionally provocative John Hancock post, concerning Al-Jazeera's efforts to penetrate MSO's with their English-speaking spin-off, generated a record number of responses. The column's unofficial "sentiment tally" would have one believe that media insiders are solidly -- in fact, unanimously -- pro-Al-Jazeera English.

The lack of any responses to the outlandish proclamations of Yusuf al-Qaradawi must, at a minimum, be construed that there is little angst (at least among TV Board readers) that the Sharia way of life -- and its treatment of women -- will ever gain traction here in the United States.

Even the response that began with, "Thank you for sharing what many others wouldn't have the courage to reveal..." followed up with, "...that Al-Jazeera has a lot to offer Americans of any ethnicity or religion who want a broader opinion..."

One journalist who might have weighed in differently was understandably, and regrettably, unavailable for comment.  I'm speaking, of course, about Lara Logan.

Readers will recall that Logan was the victim of a horrendous sexual assault and battery while covering the Egyptian uprising, in her role as a 60 Minutes and CBS correspondent. 

What some of you may NOT know is that Al-Jazeera - the same Al-Jazeera that one TV Board respondent cheered on as the alternative to Fox News - did not cover the Lara Logan story.  From every report, including Al-Jazeera's own admissions, their failure to cover this story was NOT an oversight.

Said more clearly: news of the incident was censored.

Certainly, news of all kinds goes unreported every day.  Some might argue that if it's not reported, it's not news.  Alternatively, the New York Times has coined the phrase, "All the News That's Fit to Print," creating the idea that unfit news is still news, just not print-worthy.

Regardless of your definition of news, the assault of Logan should have been newsworthy to Al-Jazeera, especially since it prides itself on getting to "the heart of the story.  Every Angle.  Every Side."  The Washington Post's Jonathan Capeheart's post of February 18th echoes these sentiments:

"Never mind that what happened to Logan IS a story. Leave aside the fact that she is a correspondent for an American broadcaster. How about the fact that a woman could be swarmed by a mob of 200 people, attacked and sexually assaulted and was only saved by the actions of a group of women and 20 Egyptian soldiers? Was Logan the only one? Is that not newsworthy? I'm at a loss for what would drive a news network to ignore news..."

Al-Jazeera's refusal to cover this story is censorship in its highest, most insidious form.  I'm thankful that the press flagged it.  But what do we do about it, other than report about the unreported? 

How do we censure -- but not censor -- the censors?

Here's where I come down on this. It's important that Americans have the opportunity to see what Middle Easterners see (and DON'T SEE), when our fellow lovers of democracy look for "the heart of the story, from every angle and every side."  We Americans have a difficult enough time, with hundreds of TV, print, radio and online news outlets vying for our attention, in our constant quest to pry the truth from what others want us to believe.  At least we can choose our delusion.

That's why broadcasting a sanitized, Al-Jazeera English network, with a different line-up than Al-Jazeera Arabic, appears to be as much about propaganda, as it is about news reporting, or culture.  It's more about "here's what we want foreigners to see" as opposed to "here's what we show our own culture."

Effectively, it's just more censorship.

A far more valuable choice -- and one that MSOs might support -- is the retransmission of the unadulterated Al-Jazeera Arabic feed -- with English subtitles.

If you're curious about the difference between the two feeds, those of you with iPhones, iPads, Symbian, and Windows Mobile phones can download free apps for both Al-Jazeera English, and Al-Jazeera Arabic.  The surface differences are striking (though I must admit that my Arabic is a bit rusty).

The AJE feed looks and sounds slick, and its content definitely appears to have higher production values.  The ARA feed, on the other hand, exudes a feeling of urgency; the guests, news content, and field coverage all seem to resonate with a sense of less-censored authenticity.

This idea hasn't been floated anywhere else yet, so drop us a comment (or 10), and tell us what you think.

While you're at it, help us solve one sticky dilemma: who would generate the translations?