Monday, August 15, 2011

On Media, Money, and Metamorphosis

“One morning, upon awakening from agitated dreams, Gregor Samsa found himself, in his bed, transformed into a monstrous vermin.”  - from “Metamorphosis,” 1915, by Franz Kafka
Welcome to DisrupTV. 
This blog provides me with an outlet to share some thoughts and observations – many of them personal – concerning our nation, the world, and humanity as a whole.  DisrupTV’s focus will center on media (predominately TV, web, and news), and money (with most attention focused on monetary reform, and the hidden ways that our current, extremely dysfunctional, central-bank controlled, debt money system “works,” and how it must be altered).
Much of the media commentary will be observational, and often upbeat; despite the never-ending flow of poor content (and overabundance of interruptive advertising) that manages to find its way onto TV and the web, there are also remarkable innovations that will prove to give more control and power to the Consumer.  As noted where applicable, many of the TV-related posts you will find here will have first been posted on MediaPost’s TV Board, where I am a periodic contributor.
On a seemingly unrelated subject matter, I will periodically post commentary concerning the unraveling of the Debt Money system that has proliferated here in the United States, in its current form, since the passage of the Federal Reserve Act nearly 100 years ago.  In collaboration with thought leaders in the realm of monetary reform (notice that I did not use the words “economists” here), I hope to provide DisrupTV readers with new ideas about money, while providing hints as to how this current charade will end, and a groundbreaking new approach that can truly help reinvigorate America.
So, that explains the references to “Media” and “Money.”  But, “What’s with the ‘Metamorphosis’?” you might be asking.
Here’s the premise:  At the heart of the debasement of our civilization, lies media and money.  They are at once symptoms of a greater malady, while masquerading as byproducts of illusory cultural “advances.” 
Both media and money can entertain, enrich, empower, embolden and enlighten.  But, too often, they distract, divide, and destroy.
In this, the era of “Change we can believe in,” the metamorphosis is the often ugly manifestation of change.  Unfortunately, the metamorphosis we are experiencing does not currently hold out the same promise and optimism, for beauty and positive change, that one would find, say, in nature’s most commonly illustrated example, the butterfly.
Instead, we as a people, America as a nation, and humanity, as a species, appear to be devolving as a function of this metamorphosis.  We are gradually becoming a world of 7 billion Gregor Samsa’s; and the pace of this devolution appears to be quickening.
But there is Hope; there is always Hope.  And over the next months and (hopefully) years, I will continue to strive to be an agent of hopeful change.
There are great ideas approaching, and a mass awakening has dawned.
In TV, there is a flippant comment made, typically by content producers and broadcasters, to thwart observations made by a courageous few, that TV is too violent, demeaning of women (and, more frequently, men and fathers), biased, or simply evil: 
“If you don’t like it, change the channel.”
To which I reply, “Don’t change the channel – channel the change.”  The things that trigger disgust should be addressed, not overlooked.  They should motivate you to speak out, push back, and shine the light of truth on those who continue to debase us, our beliefs, our values, and our way of life.
Changing the channel is the equivalent of sticking your head in the sand.  And while channeling the change may often feel like sticking your head in the guillotine, the pain is usually fleeting.  The effects, however, are cumulative.
And necessary.

Friday, April 1, 2011

Beware the Ideas of March


First published on MediaPost, March 31, 2011

At last June's D8 Conference, Steve Jobs made some astute remarks about the TV industry's seemingly insurmountable roadblocks to innovation.  Critics and fans alike posited that Jobs was posing as a decoy, while Apple geared up for a sneak attack into the TV space.

"The problem with innovation in the TV industry is the go-to-market strategy," he said. "The TV industry has a subsidized model that gives everyone a set top box for free. So no one wants to buy a box. Ask TiVo, ask Roku, ask us... ask Google in a few months.

"So all you can do is ADD a box to the TV. You just end up with a table full of remotes, a cluster of boxes... and that's what we have today.

"The only way that's going to change is if you tear up the set top box, give it a new UI, and get it in front of consumers in a way they're going to want it. The TV is going to lose in our eyes until there is a better go-to-market strategy... otherwise you're just making another TiVo."

Now, let's fast-forward nine months later, to March 2011.

First, in a little-noted PR release, a Tampa Bay-based company, Savtira Corporation, announced that it had reached an agreement to provide set-top boxes to America's Center, an IPTV provider to small to mid-market residences.  A revolutionary attribute of the Savtira set-top box reportedly will be its ability to provide subscribers with access to Savtira's new cloud-based video game library, e-commerce platform and Entertainment Distribution Network (EDN).  Further substantiated by a release yesterday concerning Savtira's alignment with Juniper Networks, Savtira imagines a world where set-top boxes compete directly with game consoles and personal computers, once again reigning supreme over the clutter of boxes vying for the scraps of a TV's limited inputs:

"All types of software and digital media (business applications, games, music, movies, audio/ebooks) are available to consumers on a rental or subscription basis.  Not only is no download or installation necessary, but consumers will also have the ability to seamlessly switch between devices, pausing media on one device and resuming it on another as all data, state and configuration is stored within the cloud."

Then, last week, 4G penetration gained further momentum, as AT&T announced its T-Mobile acquisition plans.  4G poses the first real wireless threat to traditional cable and satellite delivered TV content; indeed, a 4G-version of a cloud-enabled IPTV box, like the one Savtira has announced, could ultimately decimate corded TV content delivery.

Meanwhile, the air attack continued today, as Amazon announced its intention to enable Cloud Drive, enabling cloud-based music streaming of one's own purchased music library.  Almost immediately, insiders opined that video streaming would not be far behind, with music industry and Hollywood already rattling sabers in an effort to stop the rain of music and movies from the Amazon Cloud.

Finally, reports have surfaced this week that Apple's AirPlay -- proprietary technology currently licensed only to connected device makers, to enable streaming audio -- may soon be licensed to "electronics makers" so as to enable streaming video to devices such as web-connected TV's.  This would make getting multimedia content from an iPad, iPod, iPhone, and potentially a myriad of other non-Apple devices, directly onto an AirPlay-ready TV set, without needing a Mac, or special input cables.

Based on the ideas of March, Steve Jobs' observations nine months prior appear to have birthed an aerial attack on the TV set.  With limited inputs and sorely lacking processing power, today's TVs increasingly seem to be relegated to merely serving as the biggest, but not most important, display in the house, with every new box resembling an electronic remora, seeking to cling to the TV shark, while simultaneously nudging out another weaker and more obsolescent box.

Beyond adding wireless connectivity, and enhanced, passive 3-D viewing characteristics, innovation in TV seems to be, at best, up in the air.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Put Down The Remote, And Step Away From The Couch

First published on MediaPost, March 16, 2011

The virtual pages of the TV Board blog are used, from time to time, to define some of the phrases and terms unique or germane to the TV industry.

Rarely, however, are these brief tutorials potentially lifesaving.

Today might be different, as we discuss a phenomenon known as the "normalcy bias."

To those unfamiliar with the concept, the term "normalcy bias" might describe "the tendency of TV viewers to channel-surf among the same 10 networks on a regular basis."

This, of course, is a SYMPTOM of the normalcy bias, but not its definition.

In reality, the normalcy bias refers to "a mental state people enter when facing a disaster. It causes people to underestimate both the possibility of a disaster occurring and its possible effects."

You should look it up yourself, on sites like Wikipedia, which, as most of you know, has been endorsed by "The Office"'s Michael Scott.


The most concerning symptom of the normalcy bias is that people "...tend to interpret warnings in the most optimistic way possible, seizing on any ambiguities to infer a less serious situation."

As the unofficial canary in the TV Board coal mine, let me be brief, providing you with as much time as possible today to learn more about the normalcy bias, and its possible existence in your life.

According to graph data buried in yesterday's Mashable story about the growth of Internet news over print news, over 60% of you still get your news from TV --  roughly double the percentage of those who rely on newspapers, and 50% more than those who get their news from the Internet.

So here's a thought:

There's some really bad stuff going on outside of your windows today.  Seriously.  If you're spending time looking at your TV, especially TV "news," to get a snapshot of reality, you'll find several hundred channels of normalcy-bias-inducing content from which to choose. 

To see if YOU'RE a victim, put down the remote, and step away from the couch.

Now might be a good time for each of us to be a bit... less optimistic.  Perhaps today we should each take a few minutes to browse the news aisles of those with whom we disagree. 

Let's face it, on many matters, there are 100 million Americans (or more) that disagree with each one of us, perhaps even strongly.  The 100 million on our side of an issue might each serve as a buffer to the normalcy bias that plagues each one of us.  After all, the normalcy bias, especially mixed with catalytic ingredients such as cannabis, or worse, pride, can create a dangerous cocktail, with side effects including cranial thickening, and mid- to long-term blindness.  (Please see the ad in People magazine for full details).

How can we, as a nation of free people, be so divided, while earthquakes and tsunamis change our physical planet, nuclear radiation spews 2 hours away from one of the world's most populated modern cities, riots erupt in capitals throughout the Middle East, the U.S. dollar approaches second class currency status, and our own government decides it will no longer defend something as time-honored as the institution of marriage?

These things are happening.  Right now.  In our world.

And spare me the vitriol - if your first reaction is to hypothesize that this is all fear-mongering and over-reaction (gee, isn't that a symptom of... nah, can't be...), I sincerely ask you to step outside of the here-and-now, and take your mind back to a not-so-long-past year, like 1991. 

Would you have believed, then, that the events of today were a mere 20 years off?  In candor, would you have believed that these events could EVER have converged in ANY year of your future?

It's from the vantage point of yesterday, that we can best diagnose the symptoms of the normalcy bias, today. 

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Beck Backers Beckoned Back

First published on MediaPost, March 9, 2011

Mainstream media has been all atwitter over the recently reported ratings decline of Glenn Beck's popular TV news program.  Year on year results appear to indicate that approximately 75 Nielsen households who watched his program in January of 2010, have now either stopped watching, or are now recording his program on a DVR, outside of Nielsen's measured window. 

This mass exodus apparently places Glenn's 5 p.m. TV show in second to last place, among Fox's six weekday talk hosts.  I mean, we're talking MSNBC territory.

The diaspora leaves just under 125 recruited Nielsen/Beck households huddled around the warm glow of their Bush41-era rear-projection sets.  (This S.W.A.G. is based on estimates of a 20,000+/- Nielsen household panel, with each household representing approximately 5,800 identically cloned homes throughout America, each containing 2.54 viewers).

The loss of 75 Nielsen households is truly staggering.  By way of example, before the great Beck collapse, the Nielsen/Beck households would have had a hard time standing 3 abreast in the ammo aisle of your local Walmart.  But with the defection of 75 households, the Nielsen/Beck remnant would barely stand out in section 303 of this weekend's Monster Truck Mayhem.  (And yes, it's on SUNDAY, SUNDAY!)

Like Beck, I, too, would love to figure out how George Soros got  ahold of those 75 names.  Thanks in large part to Beck, many are keenly aware that the billionaire Quantum fund kingpin has already, nearly singlehandedly, destroyed the currencies of five nations, and now has America firmly in his sights.

But, recruiting 75 well-insulated Nielsen/Beck households, and convincing them to watch something else -- anything else -- well, that's just plain diabolical.

Unfortunately for Glenn, and unfair stereotypes aside, the news only gets worse.  Shining the light of truth on the Soros tentacles might actually stop the extradition of many within the 125 household remnant. But how do you regain viewers, in the face of the most dreaded of all truth-killers?

I'm talking, of course, about the Nielsen recruiting bias.

To clarify, I'm not talking about the bias that Beck's mentor, Bill O'Reilly, reported in 2008, when he revealed that 26 Nielsen executives, including Susan Whiting, had donated to the Democrats, while only two had donated to the Republicans.  In a blistering response memo circulated by then-Executive VP Whiting, she was quick to point out that the 92.857% Democratic coincidence is inconsequential, in light of the Nielsen overall employee base.  The memo puts it into perspective, by stating that "less than .005% of Nielsen U.S. employees, or fewer than 30 employees, made federal political contributions." 

O'Reilly missed the perfect comeback, as .005% is nearly as insignificant as .017%, the percent of households that Nielsen measures, as a percentage of all households.

No, Glenn, the recruiting bias impacts your show, probably more than any other show, because  somewhere around 60% of all households that are asked to become Nielsen households, reportedly refuse to participate.  This majority of households  --  60+ million of them -- are not even eligible to be counted by Nielsen.  (Sounds a lot like America's majority, when it comes to socialized health care, doesn't it now?)
These ostracized households would likely detest the invasive monitoring of their every view.  They would, in most instances, summarily reject the paltry sum of inflated (and now nearly worthless) Federal Reserve Notes offered up as a ransom for the liberties and privacy of every man, woman, and child in their homes.

In other words, they would be more inclined to watch the "Glenn Beck Show."

And finally, there's Glenn's recent  warnings about Google, which can't be helping to grow his TV audience, either.  Quoting Google's former CEO, Beck alerted his viewers about the search giant's prognostication prowess:  "We know roughly who you are, roughly what you care about, roughly who your friends are. Google knows to within a foot of where you are."

Gee, sound like anybody you know?

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Censure The Censors

First published on MediaPost, March 2, 2011

Last Wednesday's intentionally provocative John Hancock post, concerning Al-Jazeera's efforts to penetrate MSO's with their English-speaking spin-off, generated a record number of responses. The column's unofficial "sentiment tally" would have one believe that media insiders are solidly -- in fact, unanimously -- pro-Al-Jazeera English.

The lack of any responses to the outlandish proclamations of Yusuf al-Qaradawi must, at a minimum, be construed that there is little angst (at least among TV Board readers) that the Sharia way of life -- and its treatment of women -- will ever gain traction here in the United States.

Even the response that began with, "Thank you for sharing what many others wouldn't have the courage to reveal..." followed up with, "...that Al-Jazeera has a lot to offer Americans of any ethnicity or religion who want a broader opinion..."

One journalist who might have weighed in differently was understandably, and regrettably, unavailable for comment.  I'm speaking, of course, about Lara Logan.

Readers will recall that Logan was the victim of a horrendous sexual assault and battery while covering the Egyptian uprising, in her role as a 60 Minutes and CBS correspondent. 

What some of you may NOT know is that Al-Jazeera - the same Al-Jazeera that one TV Board respondent cheered on as the alternative to Fox News - did not cover the Lara Logan story.  From every report, including Al-Jazeera's own admissions, their failure to cover this story was NOT an oversight.

Said more clearly: news of the incident was censored.

Certainly, news of all kinds goes unreported every day.  Some might argue that if it's not reported, it's not news.  Alternatively, the New York Times has coined the phrase, "All the News That's Fit to Print," creating the idea that unfit news is still news, just not print-worthy.

Regardless of your definition of news, the assault of Logan should have been newsworthy to Al-Jazeera, especially since it prides itself on getting to "the heart of the story.  Every Angle.  Every Side."  The Washington Post's Jonathan Capeheart's post of February 18th echoes these sentiments:

"Never mind that what happened to Logan IS a story. Leave aside the fact that she is a correspondent for an American broadcaster. How about the fact that a woman could be swarmed by a mob of 200 people, attacked and sexually assaulted and was only saved by the actions of a group of women and 20 Egyptian soldiers? Was Logan the only one? Is that not newsworthy? I'm at a loss for what would drive a news network to ignore news..."

Al-Jazeera's refusal to cover this story is censorship in its highest, most insidious form.  I'm thankful that the press flagged it.  But what do we do about it, other than report about the unreported? 

How do we censure -- but not censor -- the censors?

Here's where I come down on this. It's important that Americans have the opportunity to see what Middle Easterners see (and DON'T SEE), when our fellow lovers of democracy look for "the heart of the story, from every angle and every side."  We Americans have a difficult enough time, with hundreds of TV, print, radio and online news outlets vying for our attention, in our constant quest to pry the truth from what others want us to believe.  At least we can choose our delusion.

That's why broadcasting a sanitized, Al-Jazeera English network, with a different line-up than Al-Jazeera Arabic, appears to be as much about propaganda, as it is about news reporting, or culture.  It's more about "here's what we want foreigners to see" as opposed to "here's what we show our own culture."

Effectively, it's just more censorship.

A far more valuable choice -- and one that MSOs might support -- is the retransmission of the unadulterated Al-Jazeera Arabic feed -- with English subtitles.

If you're curious about the difference between the two feeds, those of you with iPhones, iPads, Symbian, and Windows Mobile phones can download free apps for both Al-Jazeera English, and Al-Jazeera Arabic.  The surface differences are striking (though I must admit that my Arabic is a bit rusty).

The AJE feed looks and sounds slick, and its content definitely appears to have higher production values.  The ARA feed, on the other hand, exudes a feeling of urgency; the guests, news content, and field coverage all seem to resonate with a sense of less-censored authenticity.

This idea hasn't been floated anywhere else yet, so drop us a comment (or 10), and tell us what you think.

While you're at it, help us solve one sticky dilemma: who would generate the translations?

Thursday, February 17, 2011

I'll Take 'Game Show Guillotines' For $600, Alex

First published on MediaPost, February 16, 2011.

This evening, the world learns the answer to the burning question on everybody's mind: "Are the TV game shows of the future safe for humanity?"  Personally, I believe all game shows are in jeopardy unless the producers and networks embrace the reality that it's not an IBM supercomputer that threatens to make on-air game show contestants -- and the genre -- irrelevant.

The real assassins will be the TV executives who continue to let everybody -- with the exception of the at-home audience -- be an integral part of the TV game show experience.  I'll say it again - WE WANT TO PLAY. Offering viewers silly (and often misleadingly costly) side games, like the litigation-ridden, text-message-revenue-driven Magic Suitcase distraction, does little to engage viewers in an increasingly connected world.

First, however, some casual "Jeopardy" observations from a less-than-casual game show enthusiast:

The special edition game of "Jeopardy" between Watson, the IBM super computer array, and the two best players in "Jeopardy" history, Ken Jennings and Brad Rutter, has received a lot of attention from the media, and presumably, the public.  Going into this evening's third and final game, Watson is heavily favored after having doubled the cumulative scores of his fleshy foes in the first "game."

Watson has two unfair advantages, the first of which has been quietly discussed in some circles for weeks, including a report posted by PBS.  It appears that Watson is amazingly deft at timing the important button presses that allow one player -- mostly Watson, as it turns out -- to answer, while locking out the others.  I don't quite understand the algorithm used to "clear" the circuits to allow the players to "ring in," but I am certain that a computer has an advantage in that subtle, but most vital, department. Especially since Watson can't hear, and is fed the questions via digital text; how else would it know when it is safe to hit the trigger, if not by some formula tied directly to the computer or switch that "opens the lines"? (My gut - for Game Two this evening, IBM will have slowed Watson's trigger reflex, giving Ken and Brad a sporting chance.  Shades of the Roman Coliseum, merged with the $64,000 Question scandal... oh, but it's for charity... right.)

The other advantage is purely mathematical.  Trigger-advantage aside, if indeed the exposition is a battle between "man and machine," then having two virtually equal, human "Jeopardy" geniuses on the same stage actually gives Watson an advantage, in the long run.  One human ends up eroding into the other human's chances (sort of like the Tea Party's impact on the Republican Party candidates in the upcoming elections). 

At this high level of trivia games, Ken and Brad, cumulatively, likely know 85% of all answers, leaving the number of questions that only one human knows at a pretty low percentage.  Watson, on the other hand, seems to be adept at answering questions that are extremely difficult, but stumbles on the easy questions, which would, with high certainty, likely go to either one of the humans.

A more favorable (and entertaining) simian outcome, therefore, would find Watson competing against only one of the two "Jeopardy" champions, filling the third spot with, say, Karl Pilkington.  Or perhaps even Lindsay Lohan.  (Well, maybe not Lindsay - she'd probably end up stealing the show.  Click here for your choice of rimshots...)

Observations aside, however, inquiring TV Board readers want to know, "Is this the future of TV game shows?  Or do game shows even HAVE a future?"

Granted, the celebrity-versions of game shows have been a tried and true, if not cyclical staple of many game show franchises.  At-home audiences may, at least temporarily, be curious about a celebrity's mental prowess.  They may tune in just to see if she's wearing the latest from Dolce and Gabbana.  Or, now, how many terabytes of data it houses.

And, certainly Watson's celebrity is undeniable; on Tuesday, a Google News survey comparing "this week" results for "Watson," "Sheen," and "Lohan," returned 19,100, 10,200, and 9,370, respectively. 

But, much like the celebrity-versions of TV game shows, audience interest wanes.  Which means Watson may move on to less challenging game shows (for a computer), such as "Wheel of Fortune" (early Vegas odds, Watson, 1:5), or, more challenging games like "Family Feud" or "Million Dollar Money Drop," where intuition and knowledge of human sentiment often trumps sheer data retrieval power.

Either way, the "viewing" audience, with smart phones, laptops, and tablets in hand, is increasingly hungry for engaging content - and TV is NOT delivering.  To make matters worse, no genre of TV programming - NONE - provides a better onramp to interactive and reactive television, meaning that no genre today wastes a greater opportunity.

Consider "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire," which reportedly captured over 75% of America's viewers in its first year on national television.  One reason why it's been remanded to syndication is because its viewers gradually came to recognize that the more appropriate title should have been, "You Won't EVER Be a Millionaire Sitting At Home Watching This Program - I Don't Care How Smart You Think You Are!"

The formula for game shows used to be, "Play along at home while you watch total strangers win huge prizes."  Game show designers have changed the nuances of their games by dumbing them up, or down, and have increased the jackpots over the years, but to the at-home viewer, nothing really changed. As a result, many still sit at home, visiting the equivalent of Mr. Roger's "Neighborhood of Make Believe," yelling answers at their TV sets and patting themselves on the back for getting an occasional answer correct.

And then there's the growing audience share that texts, searches, surfs and Facebooks while dedicating increasingly less attention to content, and even less to the ads.  How do you reach them, Mr. Game Show Gatekeeper?  What's the answer?

What is "Please pass the iPad?"

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Wednesday Morning Quarterback -- On Culture, Kids, And Cola


First published on MediaPost, Feb. 9, 2011

Somewhere along the way, the media masters that have kept the football portion of the Super Bowl content fairly safe and "super" have unfortunately learned to slowly look the other way while the advertisers and agencies whipped out their checkbooks.  Some might even suggest that, as the promotions for their own network shows got racier, they've lost the ability to say "No" to a wide variety of increasingly, yet equally, offensive ads.

It's really a shame, except for the fact that "shame" seems to have left the arena years ago.  Outrage is out, and Tolerance has morphed into its demonic half-sister, Acceptance.

Truth be told, when it comes to Super Bowl ads, most adults have gotten pretty numb to the tawdry, the silly, the salacious.  But kids, well, that's another story.  And before some of you start opining that minors don't belong in the Super Bowl viewing environment, let's not forget that somewhere in that four-hour production, hidden between the sexual innuendo, violence, negative caricatures and cultural stereotypes that bankroll the evening, sits one of the greatest sports productions on planet Earth.

With approximately 20% of the U.S.  population falling between the ages of five and 19, and even assuming that youths are less likely than normal to watch the Super Bowl when compared to other traditional TV fare, it's a fairly safe estimate that somewhere around 10 million kids, out of a potential 60 million, watched the Super Bowl.

Going further out on a limb, and making the stunningly naïve assumption that 50% of the Super-Bowl-watching youngsters had a sober, vigilant, or conscientious parent, guardian, or Scout Master nearby, roughly  half of those kids watching the game  either skipped, muted, or otherwise rendered MOST of the advertising powerless.  These fortunate five million were at least momentarily deprived of the primary stereotype portrayed by a near majority of all Super Bowl ads; namely, that all men are sexist lowbrow Neanderthals. I mean, why ELSE would they watch these ads?

This leaves around 5 million to -6 million American kids watching the Super Bowl ads,  ranking the aggregate bundle of 2011 Super Bowl ads as one of the most watched one-hour blocks of television content among kids.  We're talking an audience of kids greater than any scheduled show on Disney, likely rivaling average episodes of "American Idol."

Certainly, plenty of ads pushed the envelope of propriety, including perennial baddy Go Daddy and Skechers, to name a few.  Thankfully, ads like these start out brash, sending much-appreciated warning flares. Go Daddy wisely slaps its logo on the screen moments into the creative, giving a heads up to seasoned viewers, with thumbs on the pause, skip, or mute buttons.  Hearing and then seeing Kim Kardashian three seconds into the Skecher ad, gave many of us parents a fighting chance to do the remote control juggle before the jiggle took over. 

No fair warning, however, from Pepsi Max's "First Date." 

Not that the other two Pepsi Max ads, "Torpedo Cooler" and "Love Hurts," were much better, mind you.  This duo deployed the time-honored technique of mating slapstick humor with sexism, helping cement top-of-mind ranking for "soft drink containers most likely to hit you in the skull - or groin."  Money well spent, indeed.

But "First Date," well, it started subtly enough, and then used the most powerful ad efficacy tool of all, dating back to the era of radio, to get its urgent message across: repetition.  Actually, by repeating "I want to sleep with her," six times in rapid succession, the leering male voiceover was so unnervingly extended, like a skip in a record, that at my home, it drew the unwanted attention of those who weren't even watching television, at all.

To insure that "First Date" left no doubt as to the targeted intelligence level of their knuckle-dragging legions of soft drink followers, the male character punctuated the ad with a somewhat muted, "Damn," near the end of the spot.  Even this potential "first" went down in flames, as another soft drink -- Brisk  -- beat Pepsi Max to the "damn" punch, with Eminem's first quarter rant, two hours earlier.

Now, by way of comparison, let's take a gander over at the other side of the beverage aisle - there you'll find 90 seconds worth of Wieden & Kennedy's Coca-Cola creations.  Two exceptionally well produced ads, one featuring border guards who find a way to stifle their animosity long enough to share a Coke (and a smile), and an epic one -minute animation, "Dragon," depicting feuding factions of fantasy creatures, who uncover the mystical, magical powers brought on by drinking Coca-Cola.

So, to recap:  One cola captured our imaginations, in a manner suitable for, and comprehensible by, every age group, while the other left nothing to the imagination, in as unsettling a way as could be imagined.

I can't be alone on this, can I? 

I recognize the game is over; we've moved onto more news, different ads, etc.  It's a new day, so, one might say, "Let it go."
T
hen why can't I get this thought out of my head?

I want a Coca Cola. I want a Coca Cola. I want a Coca Cola.  I want a Coca Cola.  I want a Coca Cola.  I want a Coca Cola.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Who Wants to Play?


First published by MediaPost, Feb. 2, 2011

There's something about the Super Bowl that brings out the underdog in all of us.  It even makes some of us want to make a bold, disruptive proclamation -- and today is as good a time as any.

Certainly, it wouldn't be the first time disruptive predictions surrounded the "Big Game."  It all started with Joe Namath's brazen 1969 pre-announcement, claiming with utter certainty that his lowly AFL Jets would defeat the storied NFL, and their equally storied Colts.

"Broadway" Joe, borrowing from his nickname, already understood, 40 years ago, that the Super Bowl provided a remarkable stage; a stage increasingly set for the three "Ps": Performance, Prognostication, and of course, Promotion.

Advertisers and promoters began getting into the mix in the 1970s and '80s, as a wave of promotions offered consumers a chance to, if not be IN the game, at least GO to the game.  Of course, the odds were always slim, and these promotions consistently preyed on the singular characteristic of every underdog.  Namely, hope.

Interestingly enough, this year also happens to mark the 25th anniversary of perhaps the greatest promotional disruption of all time.  The contest's sponsor had designed a complex, 8-week "Monday Night Winning Line-up" scratch game, where the odds against winning the grand prize -- Super Bowl tickets for eight, accommodations, and a round trip travel on a Lear Jet -- bordered on the realm of impossibility.  Heck, one would have had better odds trying to compete successfully against the Nielsen monopoly, in the TV ratings industry, than figure that game out...

However, several weeks before the promotion had ended, one inquisitive and determined future MediaPost contributor came forward, and predicted that he could "break the game open."  To prove it, in front of a room of executives and attorneys, the 23-year-old gamer turned a new game piece into a $5,500 winning ticket in less than 30 seconds.  Thousands of virgin game pieces were stacked nearby.  It was decision time.
Instead of seizing the opportunity, and crowning the contestant as a Super Bowl winner, thereby capitalizing on the feel-good, underdog fanfare that would certainly create a positive halo effect for the brands involved, the now defunct mega-consumer products company refused to bend.

Weeks later, the company received in the mail winning game pieces that could have resulted in the awarding of over 16,000 Super Bowl XX tickets; instead, the contestant opted only for 4 tickets... and $20+ million in alternate prizes.

The Goliath company cancelled the game, nationally, and the rest, as they say, is history.

Or, is it?

Something about that event, 25 years ago, still resonates with me, today.  Having watched Super Bowl promotions and advertising "evolve" over the last quarter century, I continue to be frustrated with the lack of ingenuity displayed by those with millions to spend on garnering attention.  From my perspective, agencies and brands continue to miss (or, more accurately, ignore) the real sentiment that our underdog tendencies belie: 

Most of us want to be in the game.

Which brings us to today -- where, 100 hours from now, 100 million people will be watching 100 ads, each costing nearly $100,000 per second to air.  When it's over, there will have been over 10 billion impressions served over the course of the Super Bowl broadcast.

Amidst all of these absolutely staggering numbers, I ask you:  Where's the fun?  Where does the playful, festive environment of Super Bowl Sunday truly capture the imaginations -- and reactions -- of nearly half the population of the world's greatest nation?

In short, what are they doing to engage the underdogs in all of us?

Sadly, not enough.

I think the most valuable underdogs, just itching to get in the game, are the owners of the nearly 40 million camera-enabled, web-connected smartphones, each in close proximity to TV screens airing the Super Bowl, who are almost completely disconnected from the game and its ads.

Sorry, Audi, but an invitation to tweet doesn't quite cut it.

Candidly, this mass convergence of inactivity represents the greatest lost opportunity in digital marketing history.  Think about it - that's almost 40 million viewers who want to be in the game, and should be in the game, in one fashion or another, but who are essentially being ignored by a tried and "true" advertising model that's (thankfully) seen its better, and last, waning days.

I offer this challenge to you, the TV and advertising industry insiders who read this post:

Let's make this Super Bowl the LAST Super Bowl that ignores the power of 100 million connected and excited viewers.

Furthermore, in the tradition of disruptive underdogs from Super Bowls past, I throw this prediction into the mix: 

Next year, somebody attentively watching the 2012 Super Bowl (and its ads), with a web-connected phone in hand, will win $1 million.

My logic (and math) is simple:  With 10 billion impressions to be garnered, an investment of 1/100th of one cent per impression, and a bit of underdog creativity,  someone could make this one of the highest-returning promotions in TV history.

And along these lines, here's my "Over and Under" for next year's Super Bowl XLVI:  10.  As in, the number of "reactive" ads that will feature a HyperScanÒ or unbranded QR code, augmented reality technology, an app-enabled offer, or a web-based, immediate call-to-action element.

What do YOU think?  Will next year's Super Bowl ads and promotions finally take advantage of the critical mass of 100 million playful participants, and monetize paid attention, with prizes in return?  And how many 2012 Super Bowl ads do YOU believe will feature reactive elements?

Let's hear your predictions.  And, better yet, let's work together to put the underdogs in the game, next year.

After all, the Jets may not make it -- but there's no reason why we can't play.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Thanks, Steve

 First published on MediaPost, Jan. 19, 2011

A small group of disruptive technologists and I spent the day yesterday in Ft. Myers, Fla. where we had the chance to dine at the Edison House.  Pictures of Thomas Edison and friends donned the walls, and as we all reclined there, using our iPhones and iPads to communicate and demonstrate our visions, there was something very eerie about the whole experience.  Edison's awarded patents (1,093) have touched all of our lives, and I'm certain that almost nothing we did yesterday could have happened as it did, had Mr. Edison not graced us with his presence (and vision).

On the drive back, some of us learned that Steve Jobs (230+ patents) was taking (another) leave of absence from Apple, again for health reasons.  Foreign markets were reacting negatively to this third such event, and at the time I wrote this post, Apple stock is down close to 5%.  Pundits and fans alike have started hypothesizing about the announcement's impact on future Apple devices (iPhone 5, iPad2), and the potential that Google and Microsoft could gain from Apple's loss.

Ironically, over the prior week I had begun working on today's column, with an eye to providing some personal insights into how Apple might innovate the TV space over the next 24 months.  Candidly, most don't recognize the impact Apple has already had on the industry -- and it's something I hope to investigate a bit more over the coming weeks.

But for today, right now, it seems almost... disrespectful.

Steve Jobs and his family are going through something very difficult.  His departure from Apple, to focus on his health and family, means that the corporate culture and creative energies that Apple afforded him are now no longer there to distract him from the task at hand.  It's difficult for many of us to even stop and empathize with the human toll posed by a reoccurring, potentially lethal disease on anyone, let alone a billionaire technology celebrity.

To far too many, including myself, Steve Jobs, the human, had become Steve Jobs, the icon.

Despite anyone's personal feelings about Steve and Apple, it might be good for all of us to take a deep breath, pause a moment from the task at hand, and imagine what brother Steve is dealing with right now.

Today.

Today provides us all with a timely opportunity to do something we have failed to do, far too often, when a true genius withdraws from public integration.

And that's to say, "Thank you."

Sure, much like the growing mindset we all have towards TV and the commercials that once subsidized the TV experience, the fact that many of us have paid for our Apple devices, just as we have seemingly paid for our TV services, seems to eliminate the need to say "Thank you."  Indeed, many feel that no thanks are in order, particularly if we're not customers, or, if we are customers, when the price paid begrudgingly exceeded some internal value proposition.

But dollars do not thanks make, and a visionary's impact on culture far exceeds the boundaries of an invoice.

So, for the record, and from the heart:

"Thanks, Steve."